Benson Boone Responds To Harry Styles Copying Accusations

Hugo van Dijk

4 min read

Post on May 10, 2025

4.3

Share

H2: The Initial Accusations and Online Reaction

The online debate ignited when eagle-eyed fans and music critics noticed uncanny similarities between "In the Stars" and "As It Was." Specific elements cited include comparable melodies, rhythmic structures, and even overlapping chord progressions. These perceived parallels quickly fueled a wildfire of discussions across various social media platforms.

• Specific musical similarities: Many pointed to the similar basslines, the overall tempo and feel of the songs, and a strikingly similar pre-chorus melody as evidence of potential copying.
• Examples of online discussions and hashtags: Hashtags like #BooneVsStyles, #CopyingAccusations, and #MusicalPlagiarism trended, with countless posts comparing audio snippets and analyzing the musical structure of both tracks.
• Initial impact on public perception: The controversy immediately impacted public perception, creating a division among fans of both artists. Some defended Styles, attributing the similarities to common musical tropes, while others voiced strong support for Boone, accusing Styles of plagiarism.

H2: Benson Boone's Official Response

While Benson Boone hasn't issued a formal, public statement directly addressing the "copying" accusations, his actions and silence speak volumes. His continued promotion of "In the Stars" and lack of direct engagement with the online discussions suggest a strategy of indirect response, letting the music speak for itself. This contrasts with more outspoken reactions seen in similar controversies.

• Direct quotes from Boone's response (if available): As of now, no official statement from Boone is available, leaving room for speculation.
• Summary of his main points and arguments: In the absence of a direct response, one can interpret Boone's silence as either confidence in the originality of his work or a strategic decision to avoid escalating the controversy.
• Interpretation of his response and potential implications: His implicit response allows the public to interpret the situation, potentially avoiding direct confrontation and minimizing further damage to his reputation.

H2: Expert Opinions and Analysis of Musical Similarities

Experts in music theory and copyright law offer valuable insight into the complexities of the situation. While undeniable similarities exist, determining whether these constitute plagiarism is a nuanced process. Unintentional similarities—what some call "musical coincidence"—are common, as certain musical structures and progressions frequently recur across genres and eras.

• Expert opinions on the degree of similarity: Music experts have commented on the similarities, some suggesting a high degree of resemblance in certain sections, while others note that these elements are common musical devices.
• Discussion on the concept of "musical coincidence" versus deliberate copying: This debate is at the heart of the controversy. Proving deliberate copying requires evidence beyond mere similarity.
• Analysis of the legal implications of the accusations: The legal threshold for proving plagiarism in music is high, requiring a demonstration of substantial similarity that extends beyond common musical elements and indicates direct derivation.

H2: Impact on Both Artists' Careers and Public Perception

The controversy, regardless of its outcome, will undoubtedly have an impact on both artists' careers. Increased media attention can boost both artists' popularity, even if the attention is negative. However, unresolved accusations of plagiarism can affect long-term credibility and fan loyalty.

• Potential impact on streaming numbers and album sales: While the controversy created buzz, its impact on long-term sales remains to be seen.
• Changes in social media engagement and public perception: The controversy has undoubtedly influenced social media engagement, with both artists witnessing shifts in their public image.
• Long-term implications for the artists' creative freedom and future work: This case sets a precedent for future conversations about originality and inspiration in the music industry.

3. Conclusion

The Benson Boone and Harry Styles "copying" controversy highlights the complex relationship between musical inspiration and plagiarism. While undeniable similarities exist between "In the Stars" and "As It Was," definitively labeling one as a copy of the other requires more than just subjective interpretations of shared melodic elements. Benson Boone's response (or lack thereof) has also added another layer to the debate, emphasizing the strategic considerations involved in addressing such controversies. Expert opinions underscore the challenges in legally defining plagiarism in music, emphasizing the fine line between coincidence and intentional appropriation. The long-term impact on both artists' careers remains to be seen.

What are your thoughts on the Benson Boone and Harry Styles "copying" controversy? Share your perspective in the comments below! Let's discuss the nuances of musical similarity, songwriting, and the impact of these accusations on Benson Boone, Harry Styles, and the music industry.