John Wick Franchise: Why Chapter 2 Has The Lowest Rotten Tomatoes Score

Hugo van Dijk

6 min read

Post on May 11, 2025

4.4

Share

A Less Focused Narrative

While John Wick (Chapter 1) delivered a simple, revenge-driven plot that was both brutal and effective, Chapter 2 significantly expanded the scope, introducing a more complex storyline. This increased complexity, while enriching the world, may have inadvertently diluted the narrative focus for some viewers and critics.

A More Complex Plot than Chapter 1

• The introduction of the High Table and its intricate rules: The introduction of this powerful, global criminal underworld added layers of intrigue but also increased the complexity of the plot, potentially confusing some viewers unfamiliar with the established rules and hierarchy.
• The expansion of the world beyond New York City: The shift from the contained environment of the first film to a wider, international setting broadened the scope, but also dispersed the narrative focus, making it harder to maintain the same level of intimate tension.
• The multiple antagonists and their motivations: While Chapter 1 featured a singular, clear antagonist, Chapter 2 presented a multitude of adversaries with varying motivations, making it challenging to track the shifting alliances and the overall narrative arc. This complexity, while potentially rewarding for some, may have felt overwhelming for others.

Pacing and Structure

The expanded world and plotline of John Wick: Chapter 2 arguably impacted the pacing. Some critics felt the narrative dragged in places or lacked the concise, relentless focus of the original film.

• Balance between action and plot development: The film needed to juggle extended action sequences with the exposition required to understand the complex world of the High Table. The balance between these elements may have felt uneven to some viewers.
• Comparison of pacing with other films in the franchise: Compared to the tightly-paced Chapter 1 and the more streamlined narrative of subsequent films, Chapter 2's pacing may have felt less effective, despite its action-packed nature.
• The effect of increased scope on the overall narrative flow: The attempt to build a larger, more complex world may have inadvertently hindered the narrative flow, making the plot feel less coherent or engaging for some critics.

Action While Still Impressive, Felt Less Groundbreaking

John Wick: Chapter 2 undoubtedly delivered stunning action sequences, but some critics felt they lacked the innovative, groundbreaking quality of the original. While visually impressive, the action may have felt somewhat formulaic in comparison.

A Familiar Formula

Although the gun-fu style remained a hallmark, some critics argued the choreography and fight design in Chapter 2 were less inventive and original than in the first film. The high bar set by the innovative action of Chapter 1 may have made the sequel feel less revolutionary, despite its own merits.

• Comparison of the gun-fu style and creativity between Chapter 1 and Chapter 2: While both films showcase impressive gun-fu, the originality and inventiveness of the fight choreography arguably diminished in the sequel.
• Analysis of the use of new weapons and fighting styles: The introduction of new weapons and fighting styles was less impactful than in the first film, contributing to a sense of familiarity.
• Whether the action sequences were less impactful due to higher expectations set by the original: The originality and impact of Chapter 1's action sequences set a very high standard, possibly diminishing the perceived impact of Chapter 2's action, despite its own excellence.

Over-Reliance on Set Pieces

Another potential criticism focuses on a perceived over-reliance on large-scale, spectacle-driven action sequences. Some argued this came at the expense of more intimate, character-driven moments.

• Discussion on the balance between large-scale action and character development: The film prioritized spectacular action set pieces, potentially overshadowing opportunities for deeper character exploration and development.
• Examples of set pieces that may have been criticized for being excessive or lacking emotional weight: Certain action sequences, while visually impressive, might have been criticized for lacking emotional resonance or feeling disconnected from the overall narrative.
• Comparison with the more character-focused fight scenes in other installments: Later films in the franchise arguably find a better balance between large-scale action and more intimate, emotionally charged fight scenes.

The Impact of High Expectations

The phenomenal success of John Wick (Chapter 1) inevitably created high expectations for its sequel. This heightened anticipation may have led to a more critical assessment of Chapter 2, making any perceived shortcomings more noticeable.

The Success of Chapter 1

John Wick's critical and commercial triumph set a very high benchmark for Chapter 2. The original film was lauded for its innovative action, stylish visuals, and compelling narrative simplicity. This made it difficult for the sequel to surpass, or even match, the original's critical reception.

• Examination of critical reception for the first film: The overwhelmingly positive critical response to Chapter 1 created a considerable hurdle for its sequel to overcome.
• Analysis of how audience expectations influenced the review scores for Chapter 2: High audience expectations contributed to the comparatively lower review scores for Chapter 2, as any deviation from the original's formula was more harshly judged.
• The impact of word-of-mouth and pre-release hype: The significant hype surrounding Chapter 2 likely amplified the impact of any perceived flaws, leading to a more critical reception.

The Shifting Landscape of Action Cinema

The action genre is constantly evolving, and the release date of Chapter 2 (2017) played a role. The film may have faced stiffer competition and a more discerning critical landscape compared to the original.

• Comparative analysis with other action films released around the same time: Several high-profile action films were released around the same time, potentially raising the bar for what critics expected from Chapter 2.
• The evolution of action cinema's trends and expectations: The expectations and standards for action films shifted between the release of Chapter 1 and Chapter 2, possibly influencing the critical reception of the sequel.
• The influence of newer, innovative action films on critical perspectives: The emergence of innovative action films around the same time may have subtly shifted critical expectations, making Chapter 2 appear less groundbreaking in comparison.

Conclusion

While John Wick: Chapter 2 remains a successful and entertaining action film, its lower Rotten Tomatoes score can be attributed to a combination of factors. A more complex narrative, potentially less innovative action sequences compared to the first film, and the exceptionally high bar set by its hugely successful predecessor all contributed to the film's slightly less enthusiastic critical reception. Despite this, the film was crucial in solidifying the franchise and paving the way for the even greater success of the subsequent chapters. So, what are your thoughts? Do you agree with the lower John Wick: Chapter 2 Rotten Tomatoes score? Share your opinions on the John Wick franchise and discuss your favorite chapter below!