Stephen King Compares Stranger Things And IT: Key Similarities And Differences

Hugo van Dijk

5 min read

Post on May 10, 2025

4.1

Share

Shared Thematic Elements: Childhood Trauma and the Power of Friendship

Both Stranger Things and IT resonate deeply because they tap into universal experiences and anxieties. At their core, both stories showcase the devastating impact of childhood trauma and the vital role of friendship in overcoming seemingly insurmountable odds.

The Importance of Childhood Innocence Lost

Both narratives effectively portray the vulnerability of children facing unimaginable horrors. In Stranger Things, Will Byers' abduction into the Upside Down shatters his innocence and leaves lasting psychological scars. Eleven's traumatic past at Hawkins National Laboratory underscores the fragility of childhood and the lasting consequences of abuse. Similarly, in IT, the Losers Club confronts the terrifying Pennywise, an entity that preys on their deepest fears, violating their childhood innocence in horrific ways.

• The vulnerability of children as targets for evil entities: Both stories highlight how children, due to their naiveté and limited power, are particularly vulnerable to supernatural threats.
• The lasting psychological impact of childhood trauma: The psychological scars of these experiences linger throughout both narratives, influencing the characters' actions and relationships.
• The strength found in confronting fear together: Facing these traumas together allows the children to find resilience and strength they wouldn't possess alone.

The Power of Friendship Against Overwhelming Odds

The strength of the bonds between friends forms the bedrock of both stories. The Losers Club in IT, despite their individual flaws and differences, unite against the terrifying Pennywise, drawing strength from their camaraderie. Their bond allows them to face their fears and ultimately conquer the evil that haunts their town. Similarly, the unlikely friendship between Mike, Eleven, Dustin, Lucas, and Will in Stranger Things proves essential in navigating the dangers of the Upside Down. Their combined skills and unwavering loyalty provide emotional support and strategic advantages in their battles against the supernatural threats.

• The Losers Club in IT as a powerful example of childhood camaraderie: Their unwavering loyalty and deep friendship provide the emotional core of the story.
• The bond between Mike, Eleven, Dustin, Lucas, and Will in Stranger Things: This found family dynamic is crucial to their survival and success against the forces of the Upside Down.
• How friendship provides emotional support and strategic advantage: Friendship isn't just about emotional support; it provides vital strategic thinking and teamwork.

Contrasting Elements: Tone, Setting, and Supernatural Threats

While sharing powerful thematic similarities, Stranger Things and IT differ significantly in tone, setting, and the nature of their supernatural threats.

Differences in Tone and Atmosphere

Stranger Things embraces a nostalgic 80s aesthetic, blending sci-fi elements with horror in a more lighthearted (though still suspenseful) manner. The overall tone is often characterized by a sense of adventure and mystery. IT, on the other hand, plunges viewers into a darker, more overtly terrifying atmosphere, focusing on the grim realities of childhood trauma and the sheer terror of facing an ancient evil. This difference significantly impacts the viewer experience, creating distinct emotional responses.

• Stranger Things' nostalgic 80s aesthetic vs. IT's grimmer, more realistic setting: The setting greatly influences the overall feel and tone.
• The use of suspense and jump scares in IT compared to Stranger Things' more gradual build-up of tension: The horror techniques employed differ significantly.
• The overall emotional impact of each narrative: One leaves you feeling a sense of triumphant hope, the other a lingering sense of dread.

Nature of the Supernatural Threat

The nature of the antagonists further distinguishes these two narratives. Pennywise, the Dancing Clown from IT, is a shape-shifting entity that feeds on the fear of its victims. It preys on their deepest insecurities, manifesting their worst nightmares to break them down. In contrast, the Upside Down in Stranger Things is a parallel dimension teeming with monstrous creatures, representing a more existential threat. This difference in the nature of the antagonists introduces distinct philosophical implications.

• Pennywise as a shape-shifting entity feeding on fear: This reflects a more psychological horror approach.
• The Upside Down as a parallel dimension with monstrous creatures: This signifies a more sci-fi-tinged horror, exploring themes of otherworldly invasion and existential dread.
• The philosophical implications of each supernatural force: Each antagonist raises unique questions about the nature of fear, evil, and the human psyche.

Conclusion: A King-Sized Comparison of Stranger Things and IT

In conclusion, while both Stranger Things and IT explore the common themes of childhood trauma and the power of friendship, they differ significantly in their tone, setting, and the nature of their supernatural threats. While Stephen King hasn't explicitly compared the two, the thematic overlaps are undeniable, suggesting a shared understanding of the power of these core elements in creating compelling horror narratives. The contrasting elements, however, showcase the unique approaches to storytelling employed by each. The shared emphasis on childhood experiences, however, speaks volumes about both stories' enduring popularity.

What are your thoughts on Stephen King's (implied or stated) comparison between these two iconic stories? Share your opinions in the comments below!