Disney's Snow White Remake Vs. The 1987 Horror Version: Unexpected Parallels

Hugo van Dijk

5 min read

Post on May 14, 2025

4.9

Share

H2: Shared Narrative Structure: Following the Fairytale's Framework

Both Disney's Snow White remake and the 1987 horror film, despite their drastically different tones, adhere to the fundamental structure of the original Brothers Grimm fairy tale. This foundational narrative provides a common ground for comparison.

H3: The Classic Journey:

• The Wicked Stepmother: Both versions feature a vengeful stepmother driven by a desire for power and beauty. However, their motivations differ subtly. Disney's Evil Queen is driven by vanity and a fear of losing her status, while the 1987 version portrays a more psychologically complex villain whose cruelty stems from deeper insecurities and a warped sense of self.
• The Poisoned Apple: The poisoned apple serves as a powerful symbol in both adaptations. In Disney's version, it's a visually stunning prop representing the Queen's malicious intent. In the 1987 film, the poisoned apple becomes a macabre instrument of slow, agonizing death, enhancing the film's horror elements. This shared "fairytale element" underscores the enduring power of the original story.
• The Prince's Role: The prince functions as the rescuer in both versions, but his characterization differs significantly. In the Disney adaptation, he's a charming and somewhat passive figure. In the 1987 horror film, he's often absent, leaving the narrative to focus on Snow White's strength and resourcefulness, thereby altering the classic "damsel in distress" narrative. These differences highlight the evolution of the Snow White narrative across different adaptations.

H2: Contrasting Character Portrayals: A Queen of Ice and Fire

H3: The Evil Queen: A Comparative Analysis:

The Evil Queen is central to both films, yet her portrayal is dramatically different. Disney's Evil Queen is a glamorous, outwardly regal villain whose cruelty is underscored by her vanity and obsession with beauty. The 1987 version, however, presents a far more terrifying antagonist. Her motives are far more insidious, her actions more brutal, showcasing a character far removed from the classic Disney archetype.

• Visual Representation: Disney's Evil Queen is visually stunning, showcasing elaborate costumes and makeup. The 1987 version leans towards a more gothic aesthetic, emphasizing a chilling, unsettling presence.
• Methods of Manipulation and Control: While both Queens use magic and manipulation, the 1987 version highlights psychological torment and a more sinister approach. The Disney version focuses on more overt actions and visual spectacle.
• Ultimate Fates: The endings also reflect the differing tones. Disney’s Queen meets a relatively simplistic end, whereas the 1987 film delivers a more ambiguous and unsettling conclusion for its antagonist. This highlights a critical difference in the "Snow White villain" portrayal across the two films.

H2: Thematic Exploration: Love, Power, and the Price of Beauty

H3: Exploring the Theme of Power:

Both films explore the theme of power, albeit from different perspectives. The Evil Queen's pursuit of power shapes the narrative in both, but its manifestation varies.

• Female Power and its Dark Side: Both adaptations explore female power, though the Disney version focuses more on the dangers of vanity and superficiality, while the 1987 film delves into the psychological complexities and the destructive nature of unchecked ambition in a woman.
• Magic and its Consequences: The use of magic and its consequences are central themes. Disney utilizes magic more as a spectacle, while the 1987 version underscores the unpredictable and dangerous nature of dark magic.
• Societal Implications of Beauty Standards: Both films subtly address the societal pressure related to beauty standards, though the 1987 adaptation does so in a more unsettling and critical way. This offers an interesting contrast in the "themes in Snow White."

H2: Audience Reception and Legacy: A Timeless Tale, Reimagined

H3: Critical and Popular Response:

The reception of Disney's Snow White remake and the 1987 horror film differs greatly. The Disney remake benefits from a massive marketing campaign and the studio’s established brand recognition. The 1987 film, while not widely seen at the time, has developed a devoted cult following among horror enthusiasts.

• Box Office Success and Critical Reviews: The Disney remake is expected to perform well at the box office, whilst the reception of the 1987 film was more muted upon initial release.
• Cult Following: The 1987 version has gained a devoted following over the years, establishing itself as a cult classic. The "Snow White movie reviews" vary greatly depending on the adaptation and its target audience.
• Impact on Popular Culture: Both films, in their own ways, have contributed to the ongoing evolution of the Snow White story and its lasting influence on popular culture. The legacy of these films speaks to the timeless nature of the fairytale itself.

3. Conclusion:

Disney's Snow White remake and the 1987 horror version, despite their vastly different styles and target audiences, share surprising parallels in their narrative structure and thematic explorations. Both films demonstrate the enduring power of the Snow White story and its capacity for diverse interpretations. While one offers a visually stunning spectacle, the other delves into the darker aspects of the fairytale, highlighting the enduring power of the original narrative. This comparison reveals the remarkable flexibility of a classic story that continues to be reimagined and reinterpreted across time and genres. Share your thoughts – what are your observations on Disney's Snow White Remake vs. the 1987 Horror Version? And what other Snow White adaptations would you like to compare?